Mariah Carey can officially deck the halls without a legal cloud hanging over her head. The Queen of Christmas has just notched a major victory in a copyright battle over her 1994 juggernaut, “All I Want For Christmas Is You”—the song that’s been the unofficial soundtrack to every December since Bill Clinton was in office. On Wednesday, a U.S. judge tossed out a lawsuit from songwriter Adam Stone, who claimed Carey’s holiday anthem ripped off his own track with the same name, released five years earlier in 1989. Stone was swinging for a $20 million payout, but instead, he’s been sent packing with a lump of coal—and a bill for Carey’s legal fees.
Let’s rewind the tape. Stone, who performs under the gloriously retro moniker Vince Vance (of Vince Vance and the Valiants fame), argued that his “All I Want For Christmas Is You”—a minor hit that allegedly got “extensive airplay” in 1993—laid the groundwork for Carey’s global smash. He accused her of “exploiting his popularity and style” to craft her own version, which dropped in ’94 and promptly turned into a perennial chart-topper. But U.S. District Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani wasn’t here for the Grinch act. In her ruling, she leaned on expert testimony that pointed out the obvious: the two songs share little more than “Christmas song clichés.” Think “all I want for Christmas is you” lyrics, a sprinkle of holiday longing, and maybe a jingle or two. It’s the kind of stuff you’d find in a Hallmark movie soundtrack—not grounds for a multimillion-dollar lawsuit.
Stone’s argument hinged on the idea that Carey somehow cribbed his vibe, but the court saw through it like a cheap wrapping paper. The judge ruled that the similarities didn’t meet the legal threshold of “substantial similarity”—the gold standard for proving copyright infringement. In other words, you can’t copyright the idea of pining for someone under the mistletoe. It’s as universal as snowflakes in a Bing Crosby tune. And to add insult to injury, the judge labeled Stone’s claims “frivolous,” hitting him and his legal team with sanctions. They’re now on the hook for Carey’s attorney fees, which, after a fight like this, probably rival the GDP of a small island nation.
For Carey, this is more than just a W—it’s a vindication of her holiday empire. “All I Want For Christmas Is You” isn’t just a song; it’s a cultural juggernaut. Co-written with Walter Afanasieff, it’s raked in over $100 million in royalties since its release, with an annual haul of around $8.5 million. That’s enough to buy a forest of Christmas trees and still have cash left for the ornaments. The track’s spent 140 weeks in the UK’s top 100, and last year, it earned a spot in the Library of Congress’ National Recording Registry. When your song’s preserved alongside “Sweet Caroline” and “Imagine,” you’re not just making music—you’re making history.
This isn’t the first time Stone’s taken a swing at Carey. He originally filed the suit in 2022, claiming her story about writing the song on a “cheap little Casio keyboard” while watching It’s a Wonderful Life was a stretch. (Carey spilled that gem in her 2020 memoir, and Afanasieff’s backed her up.) Stone’s legal docs even threw shade, accusing her of “hubris knowing no bounds.” But the court’s ruling puts that narrative to bed—Carey’s song is hers, fair and square.
Zoom out, and this ruling’s got bigger ripples than a stone skipped across a frozen pond. It’s a win for artists everywhere, reinforcing that you can’t slap a copyright claim on every song that shares a title or a vibe. The music industry’s a messy stew of inspiration and imitation—think of all the “Sweet Home Alabama” riffs or “I Will Always Love You” covers—but this decision draws a line: prove the theft, or it’s just noise. For Carey, it means her Christmas cash cow keeps mooing (or jingling, I guess) without interruption. For the rest of us, it’s a reminder that some ideas—like wanting love for Christmas—are just too big to own.
So where does this leave us? Mariah’s free to keep belting her five-octave magic every holiday season, while Stone’s left to nurse his wounds. His “All I Want For Christmas Is You” might’ve had its day in the late ’80s, but Carey’s version is the one that stuck—like glitter on a handmade ornament. It’s catchy, it’s timeless, it’s Mariah. And honestly, that’s the way it should be. This is the woman who turned a holiday pop song into a lifestyle, a mood, a reason to start playing Christmas music before Thanksgiving even hits.
As we gear up for another winter of Mariah’s voice pouring out of every mall speaker and car radio, let’s toast to the Queen of Christmas. She’s weathered the storm, kept her crown, and ensured that “All I Want For Christmas Is You” remains the gift that keeps on giving—no lawsuit required. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’ve got some hot cocoa to sip and a playlist to queue up. Happy holidays, indeed.
source deadline
